Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 6 Compensation and Savings under different quality risk compensations (US$ of 2013)

From: An analysis of economic incentives to encourage organ donation: evidence from Chile

VSI Reservation price
(1) (2) (3) (4)
0.4 × VSL 10,000 20,000 30,000
Reference VSL
 Ortuzar and Cifuentes (2000) (road safety) 37,542 3482 4782 6082
 Ortuzar and Cifuentes (2000) (air pollution) 23,380 3360 4660 5960
 Rizzi (2003) 16,562 3302 4602 5902
 Iraguen and Ortuzar (2004) 22,331 3351 4651 5951
 Hojman et al. (2005) (road safety-route 5) 22,856 3356 4656 5956
 Hojman et al. (2005) (road safety-route 68) 21,807 3347 4647 5947
 GreenLabUC (2014) (road safety) 44,885 3545 4845 6145
 GreenLabUC (2014) (air pollution) 285,106 5606 6906 8206
  1. (a) Savings in costs consider only savings to the health system. Benefits in QALY consider gains of improving the quality of life of patients after receiving an organ. To compute these values, we subtract the reservation price to the values estimated by Harrison et al. (2010)
VSI Savings
(1) (2) (3) (4)
Costs + QALY Costs + QALY Costs + QALY Costs + QALY
0.4 × VSL 10,000 20,000 30,000
Reference VSL
 Ortuzar and Cifuentes (2000) (road safety) 13,075 144,677 47,135 178,737 45,835 177,437 44,535 176,137
 Ortuzar and Cifuentes (2000) (air pollution) 27,236 158,839 47,256 178,859 45,956 177,559 44,656 176,259
 Rizzi (2003) 34,055 165,657 47,315 178,917 46,015 177,617 44,715 176,317
 Iraguen and Ortuzar (2004) 28,285 159,888 47,265 178,868 45,965 177,568 44,665 176,268
 Hojman et al. (2005) (road safety-route 5) 27,761 159,363 47,261 178,863 45,961 177,563 44,661 176,263
 Hojman et al. (2005) (road safety-route 68) 28,810 160,412 47,270 178,872 45,970 177,572 44,670 176,272
 GreenLabUC (2014) (road safety) 5732 137,334 47,072 178,674 45,772 177,374 44,472 176,074
 GreenLabUC (2014) (air pollution) − 234,489 − 102,887 45,011 176,613 43,711 175,313 42,411 174,013
  1. (a) Savings in costs consider only savings to the health system. Benefits in QALY consider gains of improving the quality of life of patients after receiving an organ. To compute these values, we subtract the reservation price to the values estimated by Harrison et al. (2010)